Cardiac time intervals and myocardial performance index for prediction of twin–twin transfusion syndrome (2024)

Associated Data

Data Availability Statement

Abstract

Key Points

1. INTRODUCTION

Improved prediction of twin–twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS) is needed to identify pregnancies that will benefit most from expert follow‐up.¹ Early detection of TTTS allows for referral of patients to a fetal therapy center where laser surgery can be performed. Complications may be prevented with early detection and appropriate treatment. The preceding events of TTTS are however underexplored and the pathophysiological triggers involved in the transition from balanced to unbalanced intertwin transfusion resulting in TTTS, remain largely unknown.^{2, 3}

Previous attempts to find improved methods to stratify the risk for TTTS include different measures of fetal cardiac dysfunction. In a study by Zanardini etal.⁴ in 100 uncomplicated monochorionic twin pregnancies at 18 weeks’ gestation the myocardial performance index (MPI) assessed by tissue Doppler imaging in the left ventricle (LV) of the future recipient showed a cut‐off more than 0.52 to detect more than 90% of subsequent TTTS cases, for a false‐positive rate of 10%.⁴ In this study however, the analysis was done based on the MPI of the future recipient twin, whereas, at baseline, both twins are supposed to have still normal amniotic fluid levels and it would therefore be impossible to foretell which of the twins will become the recipient. It would be more useful to predict which pregnancy will develop TTTS, from a cohort of pregnancies with some amniotic fluid difference (“pre‐TTTS”). Wohlmuth etal.⁵ attempted to discriminate between “pre‐TTTS” and monochorionic diamniotic (MCDA) controls using ventricular strain. No differences in right ventricular (RV) or LV strain discordance between “pre‐TTTS” and MCDA controls were found.⁵ As we believe that cardiac function is already compromised in “pre‐TTTS,” modalities with better test characteristics than ventricular strain, such as the MPI and measurement of cardiac time intervals⁶ by color tissue Doppler imaging (cTDI), may be able to discriminate between normal and abnormal cardiac function.^{4, 7, 8}

The aim of this prospective study was therefore to explore whether intertwin discordance in MPI or cardiac time intervals by cTDI in MCDA pregnancies with amniotic fluid difference not yet fulfilling TTTS criteria could distinguish future TTTS pregnancies from those only affected by discordant growth or discordant amniotic fluid volume without TTTS.

2. METHODS

This study was a single center prospective cohort study performed at the Leiden University Medical Center (LUMC) between January 2015 and March 2017. The LUMC is the national referral center for fetal therapy. In this study, all consecutive patients attending our monochorionic twin pregnancy clinic and patients that were referred to our center for the suspicion of TTTS were included. In case of amniotic fluid discrepancy, the frequency of ultrasound examination was at least twice per week. We excluded monoamniotic pregnancies, triplets and cases with congenital anomalies (including acquired right ventricular outflow tract obstruction) or twin anemia‐polycythemia sequence (TAPS).⁹ The study was approved by the medical ethical committee of the Leiden University Medical Center (NL 45251.058.13).

Each ultrasound examination consisted of amniotic fluid evaluation (deepest vertical pocket), fetal Dopplers and evaluation of fetal cardiac function. Fetal biometry was measured every two weeks.

Selective fetal growth restriction (sFGR) was defined as: estimated fetal weight (EFW) of one twin less than third percentile or at least two of four contributory parameters (EFW of one twin <10th percentile, abdominal circumference of one twin <10th centile, EFW discordance ≥25%, and UA‐PI of the smaller twin >95th percentile).¹⁰ TTTS was diagnosed using standard European diagnostic ultrasound criteria¹¹ and pregnancies were staged prospectively according to the Quintero staging system.¹² If TTTS criteria were not (yet) fulfilled, “pre‐TTTS” was defined as an intertwin amniotic fluid discordance ≥4cm. “Future TTTS” pregnancies were those which progressed to TTTS stage 1 or more. “sFGR” pregnancies were those diagnosed with sFGR and who never progressed to TTTS. “Uncomplicated” MCDA pregnancies never fulfilled the criteria of the beforementioned groups. In this group the amniotic fluid discordance remained stable or decreased. The “expected recipient” was the fetus with the largest deepest vertical pocket, the “expected donor” was the fetus with the smallest deepest vertical pocket (in sFGR also the smallest fetus).

Fetal echocardiography was performed by two experienced sonographers (M. G. and S. E.) using a Canon Aplio 500 (Canon Medical Systems Corporation) with a PVT‐674BT 6MHz transducer in early second trimester and a PVT‐375BT 3.5MHz transducer in late second trimester. The LV‐MPI and RV‐MPI were obtained with pulsed‐wave Doppler, in the absence of fetal movements. LV‐MPI was measured according to the Mod‐MPI technique of Hernandez‐Andrade etal.¹³ Briefly, the isovolumetric contraction (ICT) and isovolumetric relaxation (IRT) times were obtained by measuring the time interval between the closure of the atrioventricular valve and its subsequent opening in the next cardiac cycle (atrioventricular valve time). In the LV, the ejection time (ET) was measured from the opening to the closure of the mitral valve. Mod‐MPI was calculated as (ICT+IRT)/ET. In the RV measurements were obtained separately for the tricuspid and pulmonary valves due to the right‐sided valves’ anatomical configuration. RV‐MPI was calculated as (isovolumetric time−ejection time)/ejection time. Discrepant fetal heart rate was not an exclusion criterion, since large fluctuations in fetal heart rate could potentially be part of underlying pathological processes.^{14, 15} In addition, color‐coded tissue Doppler clips containing five or more cardiac cycles in the absence of fetal movements, were stored in an apical or basal four‐chamber view. Three regions of interest (ROIs) were examined in each clip, according to our previously described technique.⁶ A large ROI was used covering the whole heart to evaluate global heart function. Two small ROI’s were used to evaluate the RV wall and the LV wall just above the atrioventricular valves. In images derived from cTDI, the change in direction of myocardial movement results in nadirs in the curve (Figure ​(Figure1).1). Shortening time (St) was defined as the duration of myocardial motion during ventricular contraction. Lengthening time (Lt) was defined as the duration of myocardial motion during ventricular relaxation or expansion. Both St and Lt were expressed as a percentage of the total duration of one cardiac cycle. Measurements were performed without blinding to twin pairing or pregnancy outcome.

3. RESULTS

A total of 59 MCDA pregnancies with “pre‐TTTS” were included. Twenty‐one pregnancies were allocated to group I: pre‐TTTS that evolved to TTTS, all treated by laser. Growth discordance prelaser was present in 14 of 21 twin pairs. The disease severity according to Quintero stages was distributed as follows: Stage I, n=5; Stage II, n=9; Stage III, n=7. The median gestational age at laser was 17+6 weeks (interquartile range, 15+4–20+1). Eighteen pregnancies were allocated to group II: pregnancies only complicated by sFGR, of which nine were Gratacos stage I, three were Gratacos stage II, and six were Gratacos stage III. The remaining 20 pregnancies were allocated to group III: no sFGR, no TTTS, no TAPS, amniotic fluid discordance remained stable or decreased. A total of 111 ultrasound scans were available. The median gestational age at first ultrasound was 30±4 years in group I, 30±5 years in group II, and 31±5 years in group III. The mean body mass index of mothers was 25 (21–28) kg/m² in group I, 25 (22–28) kg/m² in group II, and 26 (23–28) kg/m² in group III. Sixty‐seven percent of patients in group I was nulliparous, compared to 59% in group II and 74% in group III.

4. DISCUSSION

We assessed the MPI and cardiac time intervals in MCDA twins with discordant amniotic fluid. In this exploratory analysis we have found that intertwin discordance in LV‐MPI and RV‐MPI may help to differentiate between future TTTS and MCDA pregnancies with discordant amniotic fluid volume without TTTS. Using cardiac time intervals measured by cTDI clinicians at tertiary care centers can furthermore identify future recipient twins and differentiate between future TTTS and sFGR and uncomplicated MCDA pregnancies. Identifying recipient twins may especially help in cases where the cardiac function of the “stuck” donor or extremely small fetus cannot be assessed, and intertwin discordance cannot be estimated.

The increased intertwin discordance in cardiac parameters in future TTTS twins found in this study is in line with a previous study where impaired ventricular strain was found in pre‐recipient twins.⁵ The development of unbalanced intertwin transfusion seems to be associated with early signs of cardiac function changes.

Worldwide, the MPI technique is gaining popularity and the number of articles on cardiac function as measured by MPI is increasing, but even study groups that have invested extensive research efforts into MPI acknowledge the limitations in reproducibility.^{7, 17} Furthermore, most studies in the literature are focused mainly on fetal cardiac function in monochorionic pregnancies already complicated by TTTS. Due to the limited number of articles investigating “pre‐TTTS” results regarding the utility of the MPI and other cardiac parameters to predict TTTS, cardiac parameters are currently not used in the risk stratification of TTTS. In this study, the intertwin difference in LV‐MPI and RV‐MPI were found to be predictors for TTTS, with a specificity of approximately 80%. Higher MPI values found in the larger twin in sFGR may be explained by an increase in cardiac output and potentially a hyperdynamic circulation, as a result of perfusion of the placenta of the smaller one via arterioarterial anastomoses. This resembles a milder form of the situation observed in monochorionic twins with an acardiac fetus.¹⁸

The results of our study show that tissue Doppler seems to be even more sensitive to detect subtle cardiac dysfunction compared to conventional Doppler. In line with findings of our previous study where recipient twins could be discriminated from uncomplicated monochorionic twins,⁶ we have found decreased contraction times and increased relaxation times in the future recipient twins. The RV relaxation time in the “expected recipient” showed a high sensitivity (87%) to detect the future TTTS recipient. RV contraction time in the “expected recipient” shows a good specificity of 82%. The clinical problem of dealing with a large fluid discrepancy in a selective growth‐restricted twin pair may furthermore be overcome using cardiac time intervals, since the future TTTS can be differentiated from sFGR by identification of the future recipient twin as shown by data in Tables ​Tables22 and ​and44.

Using both indices (MPI and cardiac time intervals using cTDI), follow‐up could be planned with a larger interval. This could allow a significant reduction in the number of ultrasounds and prevent unnecessary travels to a fetal therapy center far from home. However, the safety of this approach needs to be validated in larger prospective studies.

There are limitations to this study. Our study cohort consists partly of monochorionic twins referred to our center for the suspicion of TTTS, which could have introduced a selection bias. We have used the modified MPI technique to improve reproducibility, however, reproducibility of (manual) measurement of MPI is known to be still limited. This study includes a limited number of patients. The clinical applicability of our measurements therefore have be confirmed by large prospective (multicenter) studies. Multiple comparisons performed in this study may have increased the likelihood of statistically significant differences resulting from random rather than systematic variation. Correction for multiple testing is however a subject of debate, and is not always advised if study aims have an exploratory nature.^{19, 20}

5. CONCLUSIONS

Fetal cardiac function evaluation improves early detection of TTTS. If referring hospitals are able to stratify between future TTTS and MCDA pregnancies with transient amniotic fluid differences, unnecessary hospital visits or referrals (important in countries with large traveling distances) may be avoided, and pregnant women who are likely to develop TTTS will benefit from timely expert follow‐up. The potential utility of cardiac time intervals and MPI in the triage of amniotic fluid discordance should be confirmed in large prospective (multicenter) studies, validating our estimated cut‐off points. Furthermore, automatized measurements are needed since measurements of MPI or cardiac time intervals require expert hands and are time consuming.

CONFLICT OF INTEREST

The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

The authors would like to thank the parents of all twins who participated in this study. Manon Gijtenbeek is supported by a research fund of Canon Medical System Corporation Otawara‐Shi, Tochigi, Japan.

Notes

Gijtenbeek M, Eschbach SJ, Middeldorp JM, et al. Cardiac time intervals and myocardial performance index for prediction of twin–twin transfusion syndrome. Prenat Diagn. 2021;41(12):1498‐1503. 10.1002/pd.5981 [PMC free article] [PubMed] [CrossRef] [Google Scholar]

DATA AVAILABILITY STATEMENT

Data available on request from the authors.

REFERENCES